Limit-down plus settlement day: reviewing the short put trades

10 days ago
optionstaiextrading

On 11/6 TAIEX gapped down 6.4% at the open, to 38,915, and by 9:00:55 it had dropped to 37,837, almost 9% down. It was also settlement day for the 202611F1 weekly options, so a put with its strike below the limit-down line would expire worthless that same day, and selling one looked like free money.

The index then climbed back all day, closed at 39,701, and F1 settled at 39,824.

The charts follow the Western convention: green candles go up, red candles go down. Taiwanese platforms use the opposite colours.

How far can the index fall

  • Listed and OTC stocks can fall at most 10% a day. TAIEX is computed from listed stocks, weighted by market value.
  • TAIEX itself has no daily limit. Its futures contract, TAIEX futures, can fall at most 10% of the previous day's settlement price; on 11/6 that limit was 37,694.
  • Futures and options open at 8:45, 15 minutes before stocks.

So even if every stock hits limit-down, TAIEX falls only 10%: 90% of the previous close of 41,574.72 is 37,417.

F1 settles at the average of TAIEX from 13:00 to 13:30, which cannot be lower than the day's low, so it cannot go below 37,417 either. The 37400 put, with its strike under that line, expires at zero. One strike up, if the index settles near limit-down, a seller of the 37500 put still pays.

The line actually sits a little higher. TSMC closed at 2,240 the day before, and 0.9 times that is 2,016, but stocks above 1,000 TWD move in 5 TWD ticks, so its limit-down price is 2,020. That leaves 4 TWD it cannot fall. Leftovers like TSMC's, across all stocks, add up to roughly 30 index points: 37,417 plus 30 is 37,447. Using 0.901 instead of 0.9 as a shortcut gives 37,459.

Short 37400 put: picking up pennies

"It settles today. Even if everything hits limit-down, the index only gets to 37,417, so the 37400 put will be out of the money at settlement. It's going to zero anyway, so if someone will pay a few points for it, collect them before it gets there."

Whether the index goes up or down, the 37400 put goes to zero, so this trade needs no view on direction. Because F1 settles on 11/6 itself, there is no other trading day between the sale and settlement, so the index can fall at most that one day's 10%.

Selling at 10 at 8:47 made 500 TWD a lot. Waiting until 9:05 got you 0.6, or 30 TWD. The gap is because TAIEX did not open until 9:00. Before that, all anyone could see was futures falling, and buyers kept paying several points for this put. Once the index opened, the price dropped under 2 and never came back:

PeriodLotsVolume-weighted average (points)High (points)
8:45 to 8:597,9534.4712
after 9:008,4670.622.0

Getting 10 was not easy either. Of the day's 16,420 lots, only 1,628 traded at 8 or higher, under one in ten.

For that little money, the margin is not small. Margin on a short option is:

margin = premium value + max(A − out-of-the-money amount, B)
out-of-the-money amount = (TAIEX − strike) × 50

A and B come from TAIFEX's margin table. Opening a position uses the initial tier: A is 187,000 TWD and B is 94,000 TWD. Using the previous close, one lot needs 94,500 TWD; using the 9:00 open, 111,712 TWD. Put in about 100,000 TWD, make at most 500. That is roughly 0.5%.

Would the position get closed out when the index hit its low? No. A broker only closes a position when the risk ratio (account equity divided by required margin) falls below 25%. Say the account held exactly 111,712 TWD. At 9:00:55, with the index at its low, this put traded at 1.6:

equity          ≈ 111,712 + 500 − 1.6 × 50 = 112,132 TWD
required margin ≈ 187,000 − (37,837.05 − 37,400) × 50 ≈ 165,148 TWD
risk ratio      ≈ 112,132 ÷ 165,148 ≈ 67.9%

That is nowhere near 25%. The money is just tied up for the day.

This only works for a contract that settles that day. The 202611W2 37400 put, expiring 11/11, opened at 1,080 on the same day. It had four more trading days, and the index could fall 10% on each one. Four limit-down days in a row reach about 27,277, so 37,400 is nowhere near a floor.

Before 9:00, people still paid 10 for the 37400 put

From 8:45 to 9:00, futures were trading. They opened at 38,888 at 8:45, 3,027 points below the previous close, while TAIEX itself waited until 9:00. The 37400 put hit its day high of 12 at 8:48:05, with futures at 38,382.

One trader said option prices all come from a formula, so you can always tell whether a price makes sense. For the 37400 put that is true: it is sure to expire at zero, so its fair price is zero. Still, 7,953 lots traded before 9:00, at prices from 1 to 12.

Could you have sold it the night before? No. In the 11/5 night session, the lowest F1 put strike that traded was 38600. The 37400 and 37500 puts traded 0 lots all night.

Short 37500 put: 5 points more, up to 83 points lost

"The limit-down line is really a bit above 37,417, so I can move the strike up one step and collect more than twice the premium. The index would have to settle exactly inside the 83 points between 37,417 and 37,500. Unlikely."

The premium really was bigger: 10.83 on average before 9:00 for the 37500 put, 2.4 times the 4.47 on the 37400 put.

Selling at 9.2 at 8:50 kept all 9.2 points, since settlement was 39,824. But 37500 is 83 points above 37,417, and still 41 above 37,459. Had the index settled at limit-down, each lot would pay 83 points, a loss of 73.8 after the 9.2 collected, about 3,700 TWD.

Turning it into a spread cuts margin from 90,000 to 5,000

"Over 90,000 TWD tied up on one short 37500 put is too much. Buy a 37400 put as well: it costs its premium, but margin drops to 5,000, so the same money carries more than ten lots."

Short 37500 plus long 37400 is a bull put spread:

settlement ≥ 37,500           → both expire at 0, keep the net premium
37,400 < settlement < 37,500  → pay (37,500 − settlement), minus the net premium
settlement ≤ 37,400           → pay 100, minus the net premium

The long 37400 put expires at zero anyway, so it does nothing for the risk: settle at limit-down and you still lose 83. It does one thing, which is make the margin cheap. TAIFEX ignores limit-down when it sets margin. On a short 37500 put alone the contract's loss has no cap, so the margin is over 90,000 TWD. With the long 37400 put added, the worst case is the 100 points between strikes, and TAIFEX's margin rules charge a put bull spread 100 points times 50 TWD, which is 5,000 TWD. Because of limit-down the real worst case is 83, but margin is still charged on 100.

Could you sell the spread at 10? The two puts trade separately, so the table below takes seconds where both traded and subtracts the last trade of each in that second:

Time37500 put37400 putSpread
8:45:05159.65.4
8:45:07506.243.837500 put traded 3 lots at 49 to 50
8:48:14201010
8:48:1826.51016.5last time at 10 or more
8:50:23125.46.6never back to 10 after 8:49

Selling at 10 at 8:48:14 collects 500 TWD a lot on 5,000 TWD of margin, a 10% return, about twenty times what a short 37400 put alone paid. But spreads of 10 or more only showed up from 8:45 to 8:48; two minutes later it was about 7.

These spreads come from two separate single-put trades, not from spread orders filling. TAIFEX's trading system has no order book for option combination orders, so a spread order is split into its two legs and filled against the 37500 and 37400 put order books (a 2019 Commercial Times explainer puts it as "its counterparties are two single-leg orders"). Selling the spread at a net 10 needs, at the moment it arrives, a resting bid on the 37500 put and a resting offer on the 37400 put at least 10 apart. The trade data records fills but not resting orders, so it cannot confirm whether the quotes were 10 apart at 8:48:14.

A spread order also cannot rest in the book with ROD. Say you send "sell 10 spreads at a net 10" and only 3 can fill when it arrives:

Order conditionAllowed for spreadsResult
ROD (Rest of Day)No3 fill, the other 7 wait in the book
IOC (Immediate-Or-Cancel)Yes3 fill, the other 7 are cancelled at once
FOK (Fill-Or-Kill)Yesall 10 cannot fill at once, so the whole order is cancelled

TAIFEX's order type page says option combination orders are not open to ROD ("選擇權組合式委託及一定範圍市價委託,未開放ROD之委託條件"), and combination orders are not accepted in the 8:30 to 8:45 pre-open. So an IOC order to sell the spread at a net 10 sent at 8:45:05, when the spread was 5.4, is cancelled; you would have to resend at 8:45:07, when it jumped to 43.8, to have a chance. Brokers' "repeated IOC on spread orders" is probably just the system resending for you until it fills.

Short 40000 put: the index opened near limit-down, so bet on a rebound

"It opened almost at limit-down. After a drop like that, it should bounce some before the close. Deep in-the-money puts carry the most premium, so if I'm right, they pay the most."

So some traders sold the 39700, 40000 and 40300 puts. Those strikes are over 2,000 points above the limit-down line, so limit-down does not protect them. If the index did not come back, they lose.

Settlement at 39,824 is 176 points below 40,000, so the 40000 put pays 176 points a lot. Selling at different times:

Sold atPriceOwed at settlementPer lot (points)
9:011,890176+1,714
9:061,680176+1,504
10:37225176+49
13:0342.5176−133.5

Five minutes between 9:01 and 9:06 cost 210 points. After 9:00 the index kept climbing and the 40000 put kept falling. By 10:37 the index was back around 40,000 and the put sold for 225; at 13:03 it sold for 42.5, not even enough to cover the 176 owed.

All three puts hit their highs between 9:00 and 9:05: 1,700 for the 39700, 1,960 for the 40000, 2,250 for the 40300. The index was around 37,840 in those seconds, yet each high was 160 to 209 points below the put's intrinsic value at that moment. So even selling at the very top, if the index had stayed right there, you would lose that much per lot. Settlement uses the average after 13:00, not the index at 9:00; anyone selling below intrinsic value was probably betting the index would be higher by the afternoon.

For a seller at the high, the result depends on where the index ends (in points; one point is 50 TWD):

StrikeHighSettles at 39,824 (actual)Stays near 37,840Settles at limit-down 37,417
39700 put1,700+1,700−160−583
40000 put1,960+1,784−203−623
40300 put2,250+1,774−209−633

Had it settled at limit-down, the 40000 put would lose 623 points a lot, over 31,000 TWD. That day the bet paid.

Post-market review

At 8:45 TAIEX futures opened at 38,888, 3,027 points or 7.2% below the previous close, so a big down day was clear from the open. Whether it would reach limit-down was not, and in the end it did not: the low was −8.99%. For someone placing an order at 8:45, each trade left a different thing to wait for until the close:

  • Short 37400 put: expires at zero wherever the index settles, even on an up day. But without a big drop nobody pays 10 for it; the premium only existed because of the crash.
  • Short 37500 put and the spread: lose only if the index settles between the limit-down level and 37,500, which nobody could know at 8:45. The day's low of 37,837 was still over 300 points above that range.
  • Short 40000 put: a bet on the rebound. It made money because the index came back, which you only know afterwards.
TradePremium collected (points)Margin per lotOwed if the index settles at 37,417 (points)
Short 37400 put4.47 average before 9:00, high 1294,500 to 111,712 TWD0
Short 37500 put10.83 average before 9:00over 90,000 TWD83
Short 37500 + long 3740010+ until 8:48, about 7 at 8:505,000 TWD83
Short 40000 puthigh 1,960about 285,000 TWD2,583

The only sure win was the short 37400 put, but it ties up 100,000 TWD of margin to pick up pocket change of at most 600 TWD a lot, guaranteed. Whether that is worth it depends on who you are; for some people it just is not. The short 37500 put and the spread collected about 5 points more per lot, and owed 83 if the index settled at limit-down. The spread needs one eighteenth of the margin of a short 37500 put, so 90,000 TWD carries 18 lots; settle at limit-down and those 18 owe 1,494 points together, 74,700 TWD. The short 40000 put is a different trade. It is in the money, so its margin is about 285,000 TWD, limit-down does not protect it, and it made money that day because the index came back.